* Disclaimer: OveReview is reader-supported. We earn commissions from qualifying purchases

Best Mattress Pads Products And Reviews - 2024 Updated

RANK #1

Whisper Organics, 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector – Bab...

$59.99

OveReview Final Score

$59.99

Score By Features

Based on 4 ratings

Sturdiness
9.68
Suction power
8.48
Value for money
8.70

OveReview Final Score

RANK #2

Biloban Crib Mattress Protector Waterproof (2 Pack), for 52"...

$26.71

OveReview Final Score

$26.71

Score By Features

Based on 372 ratings

Value for money
9.80
Durability
9.90
Softness
9.68
Water resistance
9.18

OveReview Final Score

RANK #3

Sealy Baby - Crib Mattress Pad with Organic Cotton Top...

$20.49

OveReview Final Score

$20.49

Score By Features

Based on 102 ratings

Softness
9.50
Value for money
9.49

OveReview Final Score

RANK #4

TL Care Natural Waterproof Quilted Pack and Play Size Fitted...

$21.95

OveReview Final Score

$21.95

Score By Features

Based on 62 ratings

Comfort
9.52
Easy to hold
9.52
Easy to use
9.18
Value for money
8.93

OveReview Final Score

RANK #5

Waterproof Bamboo Quilted Crib Mattress Encasement Zippered ...

$16.68

OveReview Final Score

$16.68

Score By Features

Based on 1,358 ratings

Comfort
9.60
Softness
9.70
Easy to clean
9.70
Water resistance
9.38

OveReview Final Score

RANK #6

Sealy Baby Allergy Protection Plus Waterproof Fitted Toddler...

$29.99

OveReview Final Score

$29.99

Score By Features

Based on 176 ratings

Softness
9.70
Easy to clean
9.50
Giftable
9.70
Absorbency
9.48

OveReview Final Score

RANK #7

ExceptionalSheets Toddler/Crib Mattress Pad - Water Resistan...

$52.99

OveReview Final Score

$52.99

Score By Features

Based on 509 ratings

Comfort
9.38
Softness
9.70
Easy to clean
8.98
Value for money
8.98

OveReview Final Score

RANK #8

SINSAY 28'' x 52'' Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad Protector, 2...

$27.99

OveReview Final Score

$27.99

Score By Features

Based on 141 ratings

Softness
9.48
Water resistance
9.51
Absorbency
9.48
Value for money
9.38

OveReview Final Score

RANK #9

Crib Mattress Protector Waterproof Organic Bamboo Quilted Fi...

$19.99

OveReview Final Score

$19.99

Score By Features

Based on 2,437 ratings

Comfort
9.69
Softness
9.58
Easy to clean
9.53
Value for money
9.51

OveReview Final Score

RANK #10

2 PACK Sealy Waterproof Fitted Toddler and Baby Crib Mattres...

$34.98

OveReview Final Score

$34.98

Score By Features

Based on 1,071 ratings

Softness
9.68
Comfort
9.18
Easy to clean
8.58
Durability
8.08

OveReview Final Score

RANK #11

Waterproof Protector 27" x 38", Non-Slip & Durable Wateproof...

$17.99

OveReview Final Score

$17.99

Score By Features

Based on 1,185 ratings

Absorbency
9.90
Easy to clean
9.58
Softness
9.48

OveReview Final Score

RANK #12

Little One's Pad Pack N Play Waterproof Mattress Cover - 27"...

$21.95

OveReview Final Score

$21.95

Score By Features

Based on 7,710 ratings

Easy to clean
9.38
Durability
9.68
Water resistance
9.73
Quality of material
9.52

OveReview Final Score

RANK #13

Score By Features

Based on 159 ratings

Easy to clean
9.90
Softness
9.58
Water resistance
9.89
Sleep quality
9.88

OveReview Final Score

RANK #14

Score By Features

Based on 103 ratings

Satisfaction
9.44
Delivery
9.62
Value for money
9.24
Packaging
9.57

OveReview Final Score

RANK #15

Ruili Crib Mattress Protector Waterproof Quilted Fitted Baby...

$17.95

OveReview Final Score

$17.95

Score By Features

Based on 559 ratings

Value for money
9.80
Absorbency
9.48
Water resistance
9.68
Softness
8.88

OveReview Final Score

RANK #16

Sealy Stain Protection Waterproof Fitted Toddler & Baby Crib...

$17.99

OveReview Final Score

$17.99

Score By Features

Based on 3,480 ratings

Giftable
9.68
Durability
9.38
Easy to clean
9.68
Water resistance
9.49

OveReview Final Score

RANK #17

PUREgrace Crib Mattress Protector, Breathable Tencel Cover, ...

$39.99

OveReview Final Score

$39.99

Score By Features

Based on 427 ratings

Durability
9.50
Quality of material
9.60
Easy to clean
9.58
Softness
9.68

OveReview Final Score

RANK #18

Newton Baby Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad Protector | 100% Br...

$79.99

OveReview Final Score

$79.99

Score By Features

Based on 707 ratings

Easy to clean
9.48
Comfort
9.50
Softness
9.08
Value for money
9.33

OveReview Final Score

RANK #19

Milliard 2-Inch Ventilated Memory Foam Crib and Toddler Bed ...

$39.99

OveReview Final Score

$39.99

Score By Features

Based on 7,113 ratings

Softness
9.38
Quality of material
9.28
Durability
9.38
Sleep quality
9.51

OveReview Final Score

RANK #20

Zippered Mini Crib Mattress Protector,Waterproof Playard Mat...

$15.98

OveReview Final Score

$15.98

Score By Features

Based on 84 ratings

Sleep quality
9.90
Softness
9.58
Water resistance
9.58

OveReview Final Score

RANK #21

Rest LINE Bamboo Jacquard Waterproof Mattress Protector (Twi...

$22.99

OveReview Final Score

$22.99

Score By Features

Based on 699 ratings

Softness
9.92
Water resistance
9.71
Sleep quality
9.28
For potty training
8.38

OveReview Final Score

RANK #22

Score By Features

Based on 243 ratings

Easy to clean
9.50
Durability
9.50
Quality of material
9.72
Softness
9.38

OveReview Final Score

RANK #23

Mini Crib Mattress Protector 100% Waterproof, Without Noisel...

$19.99

OveReview Final Score

$19.99

Score By Features

Based on 2,137 ratings

Easy to clean
9.28
Durability
9.10
Softness
8.93
Sleep quality
8.88

OveReview Final Score

RANK #24

Waterproof Crib Mattress Protector, Quilted Fitted Baby Matt...

$18.95

OveReview Final Score

$18.95

Score By Features

Based on 2,137 ratings

Easy to clean
9.38
Value for money
9.18
Softness
9.33
Water resistance
8.88

OveReview Final Score

RANK #25

Kolcraft Baby Dri Waterproof Fitted Toddler & Baby Crib Matt...

$13.99

OveReview Final Score

$13.99

Score By Features

Based on 202 ratings

Easy to clean
9.68
Absorbency
8.88
Softness
7.88

OveReview Final Score