* Disclaimer: OveReview is reader-supported. We earn commissions from qualifying purchases
Mud Pie Circa Cookie Jars (Cookies) Mud Pie Circa Cookie Jars (Cookies)

Mud Pie Circa Cookie Jars (Cookies)

Mud Pie Circa Cookie Jars (Cookies) Mud Pie Circa Cookie Jars (Cookies)
$ 44.95

Score By Feature

Based on 851 ratings
Freshness
9.80
Sturdiness
9.53
Giftable
9.48
Value for money
8.18
Easy to clean
7.98
Durability
7.36

OveReview Final Score

How Our Score Is Calculated

Product Description

On the lid of cookie jar there is a rubber seal
12" x 7" in size
It is recommended that you wash your hands
This ceramic container features a lid with little glass door knobs, embossed with "COOKIES", and a footed ceramic container with embossing of "COOKIES."

Questions & Answers

How about the cookie canister? Is it white or cream coloured?

The ceramic cookie jar looks like a vintage type, with a vintage style glass knob on the lid and a silicone seal on the lid.

It looks like the knobs can come off, but how? Want to see if you can replace it?

Considering there is a screw underneath, it is probably doable, but it is the knob that makes it special.

There is a seal of some sort on the lid, but I'm not sure what kind?

Despite the lid being sealed with rubber gasket, there is air inside. On this jar, my cookies stay fresh for quite a while.

What does the 12" height mean? Is it the height of the lid and knob or just the height of the ?

Including the glass knob, the diameter of mine with the white cookie jar with the glass knob measures 11 inches.

Selected User Reviews For Mud Pie Circa Cookie Jars (Cookies)

I love it! My set of mud pies just got better with this addition!
5/5
Eleanor Saunders
Eleanor Saunders
| Sep 29, 2020
We are relieved! Months ago, I longed for an exact cookie jar like this
5/5

Though the reviews said broken jars would arrive, I decided to take the chance and order it anyway. Yesterday, it arrived and I am happy to tell you that it is in good condition. No cracks whatsoever! Packaged well, it arrived in perfect condition. I recognize that there is a weird little blip in the glaze (see photo), but nobody but me will ever notice it, and it isn't bothersome.
I like this jar a lot! I love this picture so much.

Aden Russell
Aden Russell
| Apr 03, 2021
There is no seal on the lid's gasket
3/5

Cookie jars like this one are so cute. Even though I thought it was broken, I would probably have broken it myself if I had kept it. The thing is, it has three tiny legs made of "break-resistant" material and it's on three tiny legs I have a problem with it because it doesn't seal well. A cookie jar with an airtight lid was what I wanted. This is to set Yes, I am aware. This is crazy. That statue or whatever I wanted didn't matter to me. I am disappointed. There's no stopping it now.

Eliel Hancock
Eliel Hancock
| Feb 04, 2021
It is very beautiful
4/5

Like the picture shows, this is also quite lovely. Very nice and sturdy and the size is perfect for my country kitchen. It adds just a touch of Glam to the look. There are many items I would like to collect from the Mud Pie store if they were a little less expensive.

Royce Wilcox
Royce Wilcox
| Feb 09, 2021
You can save more money if you avoid this poor quality! This utensil holder, the salt and pepper shakers, and the spices were my purchases In the cookie jar, there is a pepper cellar
3/5

Every item is shaped oddly, and none of them are It is so off-centered and misshapen that it will not fit on the cookie jar. It also has gaps on the sides so big I can almost fit my finger through them. The box is also a lot smaller than Neither the lid nor the bottom of the salt cellar fit, which indicates that it is overpriced and poorly made. Saving your money is important to me.

Andi Woodard
Andi Woodard
| Jan 19, 2021
You got so much more when you ordered this! I ordered the cookie jar, but I ended up with a set of canisters
5/5

It's an error! Yeah, I opened the box and two of the things had no feet, but I did find three white things. Glued them on again, and bingo "bango" - I had a $30 canister set! The results are not There is still the cookie jar to be found! The order needs to be reordered.

Elsie Cherry
Elsie Cherry
| Jun 16, 2021
You must have LOVE
5/5

A cookie jar this sweet is one of the cutest things I've ever seen! In addition to the cookie jar, butter dish, salt pepper dish, and paper towel holder, I have many other Mud Pies. Canister sets are something I would love to have and I am still on the lookout.

Harrison Stanley
Harrison Stanley
| Jul 12, 2021
Humidity and heat are held in
3/5

I hate it. This is awful. Heats and humidity are held in it. I stored Oreos in the oven, all of them ended up I put individually wrapped lollipops inside, but after one day, the candy stuck to the wrapper. There were no lollipop pieces in this cookie jar, but I was extremely disappointed since I thought it was so Since I can't return, I won't be able to do anything about.

Allyson Shields
Allyson Shields
| Oct 19, 2020

Related Products For Mud Pie Circa Cookie Jars (Cookies)