* Disclaimer: OveReview is reader-supported. We earn commissions from qualifying purchases
1 Eli's Sampler Cheescake & 1 Lou Malnati's Chicago-Style Deep Dish Pizza (Cheese)

1 Eli's Sampler Cheescake & 1 Lou Malnati's Chicago-Style Deep Dish Pizza (Cheese)

1 Eli's Sampler Cheescake & 1 Lou Malnati's Chicago-Style Deep Dish Pizza (Cheese)
$ 70.99

Score By Feature

Based on 35 ratings
Giftable
8.82
Value for money
8.89
Satisfaction
8.68
Customer service
9.03

OveReview Final Score

How Our Score Is Calculated

Product Description

2 Chicago-style deep dish pizzas from Lou Malnati's and a one-cup sampler cheesecake from Eli's
Freshly made without any preservatives
Standard shipping is included in the price
You will be 100% satisfied with this product

Questions & Answers

Can you tell me what flavors are in the cheesecake ?

There are at least 3 slices of each of the following flavors in Eli's Sampler cheesecake Among the flavors are plain, apple streusel, white chocolate raspberry, and turtle

Selected User Reviews For 1 Eli's Sampler Cheescake & 1 Lou Malnati's Chicago-Style Deep Dish Pizza (Cheese)

This was a very rich and delicious meal, albeit a little small in size
3/5

A star was taken off for inconsistency. I found the cheesecake to be quite rich and tasty, even though the size was a bit small. Because there was a lot of sauce and cheese missing, I deducted two stars from the rating. My last experience with this pizza was rather poor. I've had it twice before and had to throw it out. Around one sixth of the pizza was just crust with about a quarter of the rest of the pizza being "deep" dish. The outer crust was pretty short as well, almost not deep dish-like. The product is very poor quality, so if I hadn't received it as a birthday present, I would have returned it.

Miranda Compton
Miranda Compton
| Nov 30, 2020
The cheesecake I bought cost me about $70
3/5

Just the cheesecake was amazing, so I would give it 5 stars if I had to pick just one! I don't really mind the taste of the pizza, but I am not happy with the size of the slices. There were six small slices when I baked it and sliced it. As a result of the pizza's size, I would not buy it again. Then maybe I should make the trip to Chicago and try my luck there. There was just something wrong with it.

Francis Jordan
Francis Jordan
| Aug 19, 2020
The cheesecake I ate the other day was delicious
3/5

Eli's and Chicago pizza sounded great, so I went there to try cheesecake and to try it. My friend liked the tomato sauce on the pizza but I did not. Packaging was good and delivery was on time. I was not thrilled with the cheesecake but my friend liked it too. The product did not have the desired effect on me so I will not order again.

Egypt Vega
Egypt Vega
| Sep 29, 2020
In regards to the pizza, no
3/5

In regards to the cheesecake, yes. This is something I bought for my sister and her husband. They said the cheesecake was really good, but the pizza was mediocre. I didn't like the crust, the tomatoes, and the sausage was too big. The way we do things around here is we use pizza sauce, small pieces of sausage, and small bits of bread. A string mozzarella cheese was what the cheese looked like.

Tru Jenkins
Tru Jenkins
| Apr 19, 2021
You can always count on us for quality pizza and cheesecake
5/5

I am stunned. It was a pizza and cheesecake to die for. I was amazed by how delicious it smelled while it heated up. There was no difference between how it smelled and how it tasted. After dinner, I had an apple streusel cheesecake and devoured every bite of it. You can count on me as a regular. The company ships nationwide. Thanks for making this possible.

Gracelynn Jefferson
Gracelynn Jefferson
| Jul 21, 2021
You need this for your Chi Town fan! It's the perfect gift for anyone who loves the vibrant city of Chicago, its cuisine or its sports teams
5/5
Martha Vance
Martha Vance
| Mar 04, 2021
This is good
5/5

This sounds good to me.

Simon Patton
Simon Patton
| Feb 02, 2021

Related Products For 1 Eli's Sampler Cheescake & 1 Lou Malnati's Chicago-Style Deep Dish Pizza (Cheese)