* Disclaimer: OveReview is reader-supported. We earn commissions from qualifying purchases
Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count

Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count

Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count
$ 2.05

Score By Feature

Based on 1,712 ratings
Easy to remove
8.13
Easy to use
8.13
Value for money
7.71

OveReview Final Score

How Our Score Is Calculated

Product Description

A Black (For Brown Eyes) #031
It allows you to control the liner to create bold looks
The eyelids glide smoothly over the product
I have worn this for 12 hours
There is a shade for each eye color brown, blue, hazel, and green

Questions & Answers

What should I do if I twist it but nothing happens?

The same to me! Due to the fact that it wasn't working, I gave it a low rating. It never occurred to me to sharpen it. There isn't any wood in this

Could you please tell me how to (Or whatever it is) The wood is too thick to be sharpened with a regular cosmetic ?

Both small and large pencils can be sharpened with the same sharpener. I don't know where I got it from. We are sorry

Could you recommend a sharpener that can be used ?

Since I did not want to waste a dime on a sharpener that could or might not work, I threw out this product a long time

Selected User Reviews For Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count

You're wasting your time with that! It is not recommended to use this
3/5

My recommendation for this product would be to stay away from it! I completely disagree with the fact that this liner does not come with a sharpener. I am extremely disappointed in this purchase because it has been impossible to sharpen. Due to the fact that it cannot be sharpened, it is ready for the trash can, and it is almost entirely complete and has never been used. I am very dissatisfied!.

Noemi Browning
Noemi Browning
| Jun 03, 2021
Buying is not a good idea! Negative reviews can be read here
3/5

In order to replenish the gel, the device does not have any method to push it up. There is nothing useful to be gained from buying this except a small piece that protrudes from it. I know it sounds crazy, but the truth is this. What I find difficult is how this can be referred to as gel. You'll have to use a tough crayon if you try to line your eyes! There is no clear line between good and evil. Sigh. Liquid liners are again the way to go.

Lorelei Brooks
Lorelei Brooks
| Apr 10, 2021
The product is great! I really like The color is really pretty, but I will caution you to make sure that you blend right away if you don't want your skin to have an obvious "line
5/5

" This eyeshadow wears well and all day, and you never have It does not run or smudge once it is on, and it stays put once it is on. This makes it nice and easy to wash off, and it doesn't smudge if I keep rubbing my eye during the day. I, however, have a problem with my mascara. I'd like to see another review for this. will order again if this product is as good as it appears to be. This does not bother me at all, even though I have very sensitive eyes! Almay has always stood out for me, even though I have tried so many "natural" or organic products out there. There's just so little variety in eye shadows and I wish they had more selection.

Matthew Bennett
Matthew Bennett
| Jan 25, 2021
There is no way to successfully sharpen the product
3/5

I like the color of this pencil and the hypoallergenic option, but the material of the pencil casing sharpen without breaking No matter what sharpener I try, I get the same results. There's no way I can return it, but it isn't designed well to be used as a whole. Given that I only used it a few times before it needed sharpening, I considered it an expensive purchase. Another brand might work for you.

Azariah Hinton
Azariah Hinton
| Jul 30, 2020
My jaw dropped! I am amazed! My eyes have been lining with every eye liner I've ever known Hahaha, kind of funny This is by far the best gel liner ever! As we approach allergy season, I am excited to wear The lipstick glides on smoothly and has a vibrant color, plus it's long lasting as well! It is unreal how much you are getting for the price point! It cost me a lot of money for the most deluxe liners - This is NOT a valid entry Great product! I'm happy to save money even though it's as good as this one
5/5

I agree Finding this is a real.

Leona Conrad
Leona Conrad
| Jan 17, 2021
I like the sparkle in the It is a total waste of money to purchase this product
3/5

It's a little blue with a touch of sparkle regardless of the color it says on the tube. My opinion is that this can be OK for a younger generation but it may not be appropriate for more mature users. The soap and water method does not work very well. It is only possible to use this pencil five or six times before the point wears down and there is no way to twist it to advance the product. In addition to its perceived price tag, I find this product overpriced.

Rory Mitchell
Rory Mitchell
| May 13, 2021
What a disappointment! Hypoallergenic eyeliner from Almay that is far less effective than the previous one
3/5

As we all know, the old version of Almay hypoallergenic eye liner, which I had purchased for years and lasted me for weeks, makes a superb eye liner. So I bought four of these. It is so disappointing to see this current version. Each stick lasted LESS than a week because it is thick, more difficult to apply, and harder to moisturize. does not seem to be totally hypoallergenic as some itchy feeling has been reported. I feel that Almay ripped me off with this new and far inferior eyeliner, as a customer who used to be loyal to the brand. Buy it if you don't need.

Richard Burton
Richard Burton
| Apr 13, 2021
I received the product as described on time and in good condition
5/5

was the first time I had contacted this seller and I was pleased I received my eyeliner in perfect condition and on time. This seller did an incredible job and I could not be happier. I previously dealt with another seller and two items shipped twice were damaged by that seller, but this seller did an outstanding job! I really like this eyeliner, it does not irritate my eyes, the color matches the description and I will certainly order from this seller again. The first purchase I made with another seller included a broken eyeliner and an eyeshadow on two separate occasions. I'm so glad to be able to deal with a seller who sends out an item promptly, wraps the product well and makes sure it's It was definitely a pleasure doing business with this seller from my first purchase to how smoothly it went! There is nothing I dislike about Almay navy eyeliner. It's easy to apply and has a perfect navy color.

Santino Lynch
Santino Lynch
| Feb 03, 2021

Related Products For Almay Gel Smooth Eyeliner, Black, 1 count