* Disclaimer: OveReview is reader-supported. We earn commissions from qualifying purchases
Bantam Bagels Stuffed Everything, 7.8 oz (frozen)

Bantam Bagels Stuffed Everything, 7.8 oz (frozen)

Bantam Bagels Stuffed Everything, 7.8 oz (frozen)
$ 4.99

Score By Feature

Based on 940 ratings
Flavor
8.09
Value for money
6.66

OveReview Final Score

How Our Score Is Calculated

Product Description

Shark Tank and Oprah's Favorite Things have both featured this product!
It's already filled with cream cheese, so it's ready to eat on the go.
Bantams are authentic New York City bagels with none of the guilt!
Immediately

Questions & Answers

What are the ingredients, what is the serving size, and how many boxes are there?

Water, Diastatic Malt Syrup, Carrots, Scallion, Celery, Yeast, Salt, Sugar, Dehydrated Onion, Sesame Seed, Poppy Seed, Spices, Sodium Bicarbonate, enriched wheat flour (Wheat Flour, Malted Barley Flour, Niacin, Reduced Iron, Thiamin Mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic Acid), Cream Cheese (Pasteurized Milk and Cream, Salt, Carob The serving size is one.br>br> br>br>The box contains six bagels.

Selected User Reviews For Bantam Bagels Stuffed Everything, 7.8 oz (frozen)

In my bagel, I discovered blue plastic! Bantam Bagels has no quality control
3/5

br>After seeing them on Shark Tank, we decided to order a few boxes of Everything Bagels. br>We discovered blue plastic in the first bagel (the others are still in the freezer). br>This isn't at all acceptable! What exactly is going on here? br>br>NEXT STEP: br>br>NEXT STEP: br>br>NEX br>I sent an email to Bantam Bagels directly. They expressed their regret and explained that the plastic was from their cream cheese wrapper, and that as a gesture of goodwill, they would send us boxes of bagels (this was in February). There were no Bantam products at all. Bantam products do not have any coupons. Nothing. If Bantam Bagels can't stand behind their product and make things right when they screw up, they don't have any integrity. After this, why should anyone have faith in their products? Bantam Bagels, you should be ashamed of yourself.

Cecelia Kirby
Cecelia Kirby
| Dec 01, 2021
Love for bagels
5/5

We recently purchased these and are extremely pleased with them. After reading the directions and seeing that we needed to defrost the box overnight, I tried an experiment and put a few in the microwave on defrost for 1 minute; they came out perfectly soft, so I baked them as directed, and they were delicious. That night, I put the rest in the fridge, and the first batch turned out just as well, so it was a complete success! These little bites are soft, pillowy, and creamy on the inside, with a nice crusty exterior and just the right amount of everything seasoning; simply delicious!.

Denver STOREY
Denver STOREY
| Jan 04, 2021
Excellent straight from the air fryer
5/5

I cook these for 4 minutes at 400 degrees in the airfryer, and they turn out perfectly.

Rowan Burnett
Rowan Burnett
| Mar 03, 2021
Overnight, Great Bagels defrost
5/5

These stuffed Bantam Bagels are fantastic. After they've been heated, the bagels are very thick and soft. The creaminess and richness of the inside filling are unmatched. These bagels are a must-try for anyone who enjoys a tasty flavor explosion. Please don't be discouraged if you don't follow the instructions exactly; you must defrost the bagels overnight before heating them.

Anne Rowe
Anne Rowe
| Sep 02, 2021
Delicious, but it must be thawed first
4/5

These are incredibly tasty, resembling Starbucks but at a fraction of the cost. It's incredibly simple to make, especially if you have a toaster oven on hand. The only disadvantage is that you must thaw them overnight, which means you only have a few days to consume the entire box (which isn't a problem).

Adalynn Winters
Adalynn Winters
| Feb 21, 2021
Good
5/5

Very well done! As if you were having Starbucks at home.

Rowan Yang
Rowan Yang
| Jul 05, 2021
So good! Yumm
5/5
Rosalee Clements
Rosalee Clements
| Jun 23, 2021
This is a must-have! These are the most delicious breakfast treats you'll ever have! Years ago, I recall seeing these on Shark Tank, and then seeing them picked up by Starbucks
5/5

I'm overjoyed that I can get them from Amazon. They have a chewy interior and a toasted crunchy exterior, which makes them extremely tasty. This is a must-have!.

Jaxxon Baker
Jaxxon Baker
| Jun 04, 2021

Related Products For Bantam Bagels Stuffed Everything, 7.8 oz (frozen)