* Disclaimer: OveReview is reader-supported. We earn commissions from qualifying purchases
Salerno Butter Cookies Salerno Butter Cookies Salerno Butter Cookies

Salerno Butter Cookies

Salerno Butter Cookies Salerno Butter Cookies Salerno Butter Cookies
$ 11.11

Score By Feature

Based on 55 ratings
Flavor
9.18
Value for money
5.54

OveReview Final Score

How Our Score Is Calculated

Product Description

Cookies in a box of 16 oz
Since 1933, butter cookies made by hand
It has a great flavor and a fun shape
The favorite of children, the delight of adults

Questions & Answers

Do you know how many boxes this order consists of?

Three boxes were sent to me when I ordered them. I haven't been able to locate them since last year, so I don't know if they are still available.

Selected User Reviews For Salerno Butter Cookies

The Originals were not like that
3/5

As far as I can tell, they are "okay". However, they are not the same as the Salerno Cookies made in the past in Chicago. I disagree with the box's assertion that these are "The Original", since the appearance of the box would suggest as much. The one I have was fresh dated by Snyders Lance in Charlotte, North Carolina, and distributed by them. In the same way as the cookie inside, the box is a mock up of the past. a plastic tray with four dividers (about 18 cm. Two dozen cookies each) fill The Cookie has a way too LIGHT color without sloping down on the edges like the original cookie of days gone by. The original Cookie had more of a tan baked color. It is extremely hard to chew this cookie, almost to the point where it is almost hard to bite. As for taste, well, it does remind me of the original taste a bit, but it may be a little more sweet and have less butter flavor to it. Apparently some cookie makers tried to bring them back to life but were unsuccessful, in my opinion. As a child I loved these cookies, and I wanted to show someone from outside of my hometown what they tasted like. For me, this was a fail. Please click here to see the price. "I would never say "never" again, did I say that? These will take you back to your childhood and take you back to the good old days. I see online that it is much, much more expensive than in stores. A value of 2 It should cost no more than three bucks. It's Mommy or I'm Dear, Stop giving me cookies and give me Beer,' he said.

Sierra Gutierrez
Sierra Gutierrez
| Jun 08, 2021
I love butter! The flower-shaped butter cookies are reminiscent of the butter cookies I ate as a child
5/5

It has just the right texture and is delicious to eat.

Forest MARSDEN
Forest MARSDEN
| May 21, 2021
I didn't think it was worth the price
3/5

They all had broken pieces. It's not worth the price if my cookies are not perfect.

Zayne Bernard
Zayne Bernard
| Aug 10, 2021
Cookies made with butter that are the best
5/5

In spite of the exorbitant price of these cookies, I bought them. As a child growing up in the Midwest, I used to eat them with my grandparents. You put them on your finger and nibble away. Ice cream on the side is always a good choice. I feel like I am transported back in time!.

Truett CHAMBERLAIN
Truett CHAMBERLAIN
| May 25, 2021
Upon first glance, it seems like yesterday
5/5

As good as they used to be, they're just as tasty now we remember them all from our childhood.

Jayda Bryan
Jayda Bryan
| Oct 04, 2020
However, they are not cheap
3/5

They have good quality, but they are expensive. I probably won't buy again.

Shay McMillan
Shay McMillan
| Aug 15, 2021
This is a super expensive item
3/5

It was a little difficult to believe how small the box was for the price I paid! This brand of cookies has always been my favorite, but I won't buy.

Keenan Cole
Keenan Cole
| Feb 26, 2021
The cookie
5/5

I'll order them again since I liked them so much.

Foster Mays
Foster Mays
| Mar 27, 2021

Related Products For Salerno Butter Cookies