* Disclaimer: OveReview is reader-supported. We earn commissions from qualifying purchases
stila Smudge Pot stila Smudge Pot stila Smudge Pot stila Smudge Pot

stila Smudge Pot

stila Smudge Pot stila Smudge Pot stila Smudge Pot stila Smudge Pot
$ 20.00

Score By Feature

Based on 291 ratings
Satisfaction
8.42
Giftable
8.96
Packaging
8.92
Customer service
8.57

OveReview Final Score

How Our Score Is Calculated

Questions & Answers

Can you tell me if the item is waterproof by its description?

No idea if it is listed, but I have been using it for years and it stays on until you turn There's a brown color I really like, but it's hard to find -- In my mind, I thought it had been

How do you recommend you use this brush? There is a brush included in the Maybelline gel liner that I love, but it needs replacing. ?

Brush for lining the eyes with Smash Box eyeliner.

The last time I brought something like this it was so difficult. Does anyone know what brush to apply the gel with and if it can be softened up any?

It is not normal for that to happen. I usually get around two hours out of mine after opening it There are 3 months before the product starts to get old and is no longer as smooth as it was when it was new. This flat brush I purchased from Amazon is what I use. You can find it on the web under the name I love this product for the control it provides as well as the straight, even line it produces.

Do you have any idea how much oil this product has?

According to the ingredient list on the package, there is no oil listed. Moreover, it does not feel oily or greasy.

Selected User Reviews For stila Smudge Pot

A winner would have loved me but not me
3/5

really wanted to love this product, and luckily it was great when I first used it. However, no matter how tightly you keep the lid on, this product will dry. Even my face became flaky when it dried because my skin was so dry. In order for it to flow smoothly on the eyelid, I had to make sure that I got as much on my brush as I could. In the case of looking for an eyeliner pot, Anastasia is a good choice. That's a big disappointment for me. In my opinion, it deserves three stars only because when I first received it, it was great, but after a week, I found it was no longer that. There's a problem with the formula they're using.

Scout Carroll
Scout Carroll
| Apr 08, 2021
The application needs to be precise
5/5

My favorite thing about this product is that I can apply a wing much more precisely than with traditional liners using smudge pots and flat eyeliner brushes. A bit of setting powder (Tarte Smooth Operator Finishing Powder) with an eyeshadow brush's enough to do my makeup for the whole day or night. Every time I recommend my liner, I hear people comment about how good it is. As soon as it dries out, I get a new one, but it does dry out after several months. The fact that it lasts for a long time before it becomes a deal breaker is not a deal breaker for me.

Eleanor Saunders
Eleanor Saunders
| Aug 01, 2020
I like this eyeliner a lot
5/5

It was a youtube review that brought me to this. I really like this liner, even though the packaging isn't very impressive. Eyeliners have been a part of my daily routine for over 20 years now and this is my favorite. You can easily apply this makeup, it doesn't smudge easily, and it stays on all day. There is a need to take care to not remove too much product during application, as the product will start to set in just a few minutes, and we all know that can cause clumping and consistency problems if you decide to apply it further. The touch-ups may be a little tricky, but are totally possible if you wipe them down and then re-apply I am applying. The hat holds up well in surprise rainstorms and is fairly durable after a quick face wash. I do not have much experience with durability while swimming, but it remains intact after a quick wash. As a result of not properly securing the top, there has been some dry out, but that should I can use the product almost all the way until I've used almost all of it when I close it properly.

Aden Russell
Aden Russell
| Feb 24, 2021
We have approved this model
5/5

Having used Pinterest for three years, here are some tips Through a combination of editorial posts, buzzfeed makeup fails, and Stila's noir smudge pot, I have achieved the ultimate "Cleopatra meets Prada runway" look. As of today, I am no longer using felt-tipped markers It's a step up from the slightly more racy liquid liners, to the slightly classier liquid noir pot and makeup brush tier. In my opinion, this product is fabulous, but ostensibly overpriced, at least in comparison to its drugstore counterparts that in my opinion I'd be happy to pay an extra $5 if it meant I could get better service To look like a prehistoric bird, it won't cost you more than $10 The following is a brief biography of Richard Burton and Additionally, it is important to note that it took me three years to achieve my winged look without the benefit of a liquid liner pen, but it was well worth the time devoted to trial and error for the final result. In general, if I were stuck on a deserted island with nothing but four things to bring (because let's face it, just one isn't enough), I'd go for the following When it comes to beauty products, I would pack a smudge pot by Stila, a fine tipped makeup brush, a Paw Paw lip balm, and Tarte's 24-hour cream This foundation raises money for human resources.

Simon Deleon
Simon Deleon
| Mar 22, 2021
Smudge pots that are FRESH from Stila are amazing
3/5

Throughout the last two years, I've used Stila Smudge Pots to cleanse my face. It has a bronze color that I like Daytime wear is fine since it is not overly intense. It stays on and is beautiful. I have, however, only purchased Smudge Pots on Amazon two times since last year (most recently from It's obviously after using the Beauty Box), they have become dry We can't allow that to happen. In order to ensure I get a fresh product from Sephora, I'll have to purchase them from Sephora. They tend to dry out after a couple of months even when you get a fresh.

Eve Rocha
Eve Rocha
| Mar 24, 2021
You won't have to worry about smudging when Having a Christmas party with friends made the entire night emotional for me, and I began to cry while attending the party
5/5

The eyeliner did not smudge on my face. This product will stand up to tears and will retain its smoothness for a long time to come.

Eliel Hancock
Eliel Hancock
| Oct 06, 2020
I think this is the best brown eyeliner for brown eyes
5/5

Unlike most other foundations, it never smudges and stays on the whole It's easier to use a flat tipped eyeliner brush to apply the liner than a brush, and then I use a cotton swab to smudge and blend it. If you are using it as eye shadow, a little goes a long way since the pigment is very strong. Some of my others have mentioned that it does dry out eventually, but this lasts for months so I just buy a new one in that case.

Mckinley Good
Mckinley Good
| Apr 26, 2021
This does not sit well with me
3/5

Unfortunately, I am dissatisfied with the quality of this product. At first it was so soft and gelly that it was impossible to apply. Now it's so hard that it has to be scraped off.

Brycen Salazar
Brycen Salazar
| Feb 21, 2021

Related Products For stila Smudge Pot