* Disclaimer: OveReview is reader-supported. We earn commissions from qualifying purchases

Best Stuffed Animals & Toys Products And Reviews - 2024 Updated

About OveReview Score
RANK #1

Mary Meyer Putty Nursery Soft Toy, Cow...

$18.99

OveReview Final Score

$18.99

Score By Features

Based on 3,671 ratings

Softness
9.93
Giftable
9.73
Durability
9.58
Easy to clean
9.50

OveReview Final Score

RANK #2

Squishmallow Official Kellytoy Plush 12" Aqua The Sloth- Ult...

$14.99

OveReview Final Score

$14.99

Score By Features

Based on 298 ratings

Softness
9.68
Value for money
9.38
Giftable
9.48

OveReview Final Score

RANK #3

Score By Features

Based on 708 ratings

Softness
9.68
Giftable
9.68
Value for money
9.68

OveReview Final Score

RANK #4

Score By Features

Based on 1,716 ratings

Softness
9.68
Giftable
9.49
Durability
9.51
Value for money
9.08

OveReview Final Score

RANK #5

ebba - Loppy Giraffe (ebba) - 11" Loppy Giraffe...

$12.7

OveReview Final Score

$12.70

Score By Features

Based on 2,904 ratings

Softness
9.68
Giftable
9.38
Value for money
9.51

OveReview Final Score

RANK #6

Bedtime Originals Plush Monkey Ollie, Brown...

$10.17

OveReview Final Score

$10.17

Score By Features

Based on 3,724 ratings

Age appropriate
9.78
Giftable
9.48
Softness
9.68
Easy to clean
9.73

OveReview Final Score

RANK #7

Squishmallow Official Kellytoy Plush 12" Maui The Pineapple ...

$19.88

OveReview Final Score

$19.88

Score By Features

Based on 1,097 ratings

Softness
9.48
Giftable
9.51
Value for money
8.93

OveReview Final Score

RANK #8

Score By Features

Based on 1,418 ratings

Giftable
9.71
Softness
9.51
Value for money
9.09

OveReview Final Score

RANK #9

Squishmallow Official Kellytoy Plush 12" Archie The Axolotl-...

$41.82

OveReview Final Score

$41.82

Score By Features

Based on 123 ratings

Softness
9.68
Giftable
9.38
Value for money
8.98

OveReview Final Score

RANK #10

Score By Features

Based on 589 ratings

Softness
9.58
Giftable
9.58
Value for money
9.48

OveReview Final Score

RANK #11

Score By Features

Based on 2,771 ratings

Softness
9.28
Giftable
9.08
Durability
8.68
Value for money
7.88

OveReview Final Score

RANK #12

Score By Features

Based on 5,432 ratings

Age appropriate
9.60
Durability
9.68
Giftable
9.69
Softness
9.71

OveReview Final Score

RANK #13

GUND Philbin Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Plush, Beige, 12"...

$9.42

OveReview Final Score

$9.42

Score By Features

Based on 11,382 ratings

Softness
9.89
Giftable
9.93
Value for money
9.48
Durability
9.50

OveReview Final Score

RANK #14

Aurora - Flopsie - 12" Fernando Frog...

$14.99

OveReview Final Score

$14.99

Score By Features

Based on 678 ratings

Softness
9.78
Giftable
9.48
Value for money
8.98

OveReview Final Score

RANK #15

Score By Features

Based on 2,917 ratings

Softness
9.38
Giftable
9.68
Value for money
9.48
Durability
8.98

OveReview Final Score

RANK #16

Squishmallow Official Kellytoy Plush 12" Liv The Teal Leopar...

$34.89

OveReview Final Score

$34.89

Score By Features

Based on 1,469 ratings

Value for money
9.21
Satisfaction
9.58
Delivery
9.32
Packaging
9.28

OveReview Final Score

RANK #17

Score By Features

Based on 503 ratings

Softness
9.68
Giftable
9.53
Value for money
8.68

OveReview Final Score

RANK #18

Pokemon Official & Premium Quality 8-Inch Pikachu Plush - Ad...

$14.99

OveReview Final Score

$14.99

Score By Features

Based on 6,571 ratings

Giftable
9.72
Softness
9.49
Value for money
9.18

OveReview Final Score

RANK #19

Bedtime Originals Roar Dinosaur Plush Rex, Blue...

$9.99

OveReview Final Score

$9.99

Score By Features

Based on 4,056 ratings

Giftable
9.89
Softness
9.93
Value for money
9.91
Durability
9.70

OveReview Final Score

RANK #20

Score By Features

Based on 3,697 ratings

Softness
9.38
Durability
9.48
Giftable
9.38
Value for money
9.12

OveReview Final Score

RANK #21

Douglas Wizard Snowy Owl Plush Stuffed Animal...

$12.95

OveReview Final Score

$12.95

Score By Features

Based on 8,270 ratings

Durability
9.60
Softness
9.58
Giftable
9.48
Value for money
8.88

OveReview Final Score

RANK #22

GUND Pusheen Snackables Sushi Chopsticks Plush Stuffed Anima...

$17.92

OveReview Final Score

$17.92

Score By Features

Based on 10,623 ratings

Giftable
9.90
Softness
9.78
Durability
9.72
Value for money
9.33

OveReview Final Score

RANK #23

Score By Features

Based on 2,626 ratings

Giftable
9.89
Softness
9.78
Value for money
9.48
Durability
9.50

OveReview Final Score

RANK #24

Score By Features

Based on 2,324 ratings

Durability
9.50
Giftable
9.71
Softness
9.73
Value for money
9.10

OveReview Final Score

RANK #25

Score By Features

Based on 5,099 ratings

Softness
9.91
Giftable
9.71
Durability
9.68
Value for money
8.98

OveReview Final Score