* Disclaimer: OveReview is reader-supported. We earn commissions from qualifying purchases

Best Peanut-Butter Products And Reviews - 2024 Updated

About OveReview Score
About OveReview Score
RANK #1

Lance Nekot Peanut Butter Cookies - 40 ct....

$23.8

OveReview Final Score

$23.80

Score By Features

Based on 356 ratings

Flavor
9.58
Value for money
9.28
Freshness
8.98

OveReview Final Score

RANK #2

Nutter Butter Bites Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 12 - 3 o...

$30.29

OveReview Final Score

$30.29

Score By Features

Based on 55 ratings

Satisfaction
9.81
Packaging
9.70
Value for money
9.49
Customer service
9.62

OveReview Final Score

RANK #3

Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 4 Boxes of 12 ...

$17.16

OveReview Final Score

$17.16

Score By Features

Based on 9,201 ratings

Flavor
9.51
Freshness
8.98
Value for money
7.69

OveReview Final Score

RANK #4

Nature Valley Chocolate Biscuits with Peanut Butter, 10 ct, ...

$40.45

OveReview Final Score

$40.45

Score By Features

Based on 325 ratings

Flavor
9.92
Value for money
8.50

OveReview Final Score

RANK #5

Lance Nekot Peanut Butter Cookies, 69.8 Ounce...

$17.99

OveReview Final Score

$17.99

Score By Features

Based on 35 ratings

Flavor
9.90
Value for money
9.60

OveReview Final Score

RANK #6

Score By Features

Based on 1,280 ratings

Freshness
8.88
Flavor
8.38
Value for money
7.16

OveReview Final Score

RANK #7

Nature Valley Biscuits With Peanut Butter, 13.5 oz, 10 ct...

$5.98

OveReview Final Score

$5.98

Score By Features

Based on 3,022 ratings

Flavor
8.98
Value for money
8.89

OveReview Final Score

RANK #8

Nabisco Nutter Butter Cookies - 1.9 Oz. - 24 Pks. - SCS...

$19.99

OveReview Final Score

$19.99

Score By Features

Based on 302 ratings

Flavor
8.78
Freshness
8.89
Value for money
8.78

OveReview Final Score

RANK #9

Lance Nekot Cookie Sandwiches Real Peanut Butter On-The-Go P...

$16.24

OveReview Final Score

$16.24

Score By Features

Based on 253 ratings

Flavor
9.90
Value for money
8.13

OveReview Final Score

RANK #10

Nature Valley Chocolate Biscuits with Peanut Butter, 5 ct...

$7.99

OveReview Final Score

$7.99

Score By Features

Based on 142 ratings

Flavor
8.88
Value for money
7.26

OveReview Final Score

RANK #11

Nature Valley Biscuits, Peanut Butter, 1.35 oz, 5 Count...

$3.6

OveReview Final Score

$3.60

Score By Features

Based on 2,119 ratings

Flavor
9.08
Value for money
8.50
Softness
4.48

OveReview Final Score

RANK #12

Score By Features

Based on 446 ratings

Flavor
9.29
Freshness
9.08

OveReview Final Score

RANK #13

Lance ToastChee Peanut Butter Crackers 1.52 oz., 40 ct. A1...

$22.48

OveReview Final Score

$22.48

Score By Features

Based on 53 ratings

Flavor
9.70
Value for money
9.70
Freshness
9.50

OveReview Final Score

RANK #14

Grandma's Peanut Butter Cookies - 33 pks - Total 66 Cookies...

$31.93

OveReview Final Score

$31.93

Score By Features

Based on 143 ratings

Flavor
8.48
Value for money
8.48
Freshness
8.08

OveReview Final Score

RANK #15

Quest Nutrition Cookies & Cream Hero Bar - 12 Count...

$22.47

OveReview Final Score

$22.47

Score By Features

Based on 760 ratings

Freshness
9.29
Flavor
9.12
Ingredient quality
8.78
Value for money
8.32

OveReview Final Score

RANK #16

Shiroi Koibito White Lover White & Black Chocolate 24pcs...

$24

OveReview Final Score

$24.00

Score By Features

Based on 579 ratings

Flavor
8.58
Value for money
8.08
Giftable
7.56

OveReview Final Score

RANK #17

Emmy's Organics, Coconut Cookies - Peanut Butter, 6 oz (Pack...

$12.95

OveReview Final Score

$12.95

Score By Features

Based on 158 ratings

Giftable
9.05
Delivery
8.79
Packaging
9.09
Value for money
8.92

OveReview Final Score

RANK #18

Score By Features

Based on 84 ratings

Freshness
9.70
Flavor
9.32

OveReview Final Score

RANK #19

Grandma's Cookies, Peanut Butter, 2.25oz (10 Pack)...

$8.99

OveReview Final Score

$8.99

Score By Features

Based on 32,563 ratings

Value for money
8.68
Flavor
8.48
Freshness
8.48
Giftable
8.08

OveReview Final Score

RANK #20

Philadelphia Candies Dark Chocolate Covered Nutter Butter Co...

$13.95

OveReview Final Score

$13.95

Score By Features

Based on 525 ratings

Delivery
8.81
Customer service
8.81
Value for money
9.22
Packaging
8.70

OveReview Final Score

RANK #21

Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Wafer Cookies, 12 - 10.5 oz pack...

$43.01

OveReview Final Score

$43.01

Score By Features

Based on 327 ratings

Flavor
9.88
Freshness
9.69
Value for money
9.48

OveReview Final Score

RANK #22

Frozen Cookie Dough (Chocolate Chunk & Oatmeal Raisin)...

$47.95

OveReview Final Score

$47.95

Score By Features

Based on 398 ratings

Flavor
8.58
Value for money
8.53
Giftable
8.11

OveReview Final Score

RANK #23

Score By Features

Based on 11,245 ratings

Freshness
8.88
Flavor
8.18
Value for money
8.08
Giftable
7.98

OveReview Final Score

RANK #24

Nature Valley Protein Crunch Bars, Peanut Butter, 5 Bars...

$4.3

OveReview Final Score

$4.30

Score By Features

Based on 179 ratings

Customer service
8.80
Packaging
8.63
Giftable
8.62
Delivery
8.67

OveReview Final Score

RANK #25

Grandma's Chocolate Brownie Cookies, 2.5 Ounce (Pack of 60)...

$24.28

OveReview Final Score

$24.28

Score By Features

Based on 9,303 ratings

Giftable
9.32
Flavor
8.91
Freshness
8.88
Value for money
8.72

OveReview Final Score