* Disclaimer: OveReview is reader-supported. We earn commissions from qualifying purchases

Best Cookies Products And Reviews - 2024 Updated

RANK #1

Betty Crocker Snickerdoodle Cookie Mix 17.9 Oz (Pack of 2)...

$11.84

OveReview Final Score

$11.84

Score By Features

Based on 71 ratings

Flavor
9.80
Value for money
8.58

OveReview Final Score

RANK #2

Nairn's Gluten Free Oatmeal Cookies Graham -- 5.64 oz pack o...

$22.03

OveReview Final Score

$22.03

Score By Features

Based on 16 ratings

Delivery
9.90
Value for money
9.60
Packaging
9.70
Giftable
9.80

OveReview Final Score

RANK #3

Kinder Happy Hippo COCOA CREAM Biscuits 5 count boxes (PACK ...

$41.95

OveReview Final Score

$41.95

Score By Features

Based on 1,006 ratings

Flavor
9.72
Value for money
8.58

OveReview Final Score

RANK #4

Crawford's Garibaldi Biscuits 100g (Pack of 24)...

$33.16

OveReview Final Score

$33.16

Score By Features

Based on 417 ratings

Flavor
9.18
Freshness
9.49
Value for money
8.88

OveReview Final Score

RANK #5

Score By Features

Based on 558 ratings

Flavor
9.18
Portion size
8.18
Value for money
7.46
Giftable
7.48

OveReview Final Score

RANK #6

Broadman Church Supplies Pre-filled Communion Fellowship Cup...

$27.55

OveReview Final Score

$27.55

Score By Features

Based on 6,875 ratings

Value for money
8.88
Freshness
9.11
Flavor
8.78

OveReview Final Score

RANK #7

Score By Features

Based on 1,542 ratings

Easy to use
9.92
Flavor
9.18
Value for money
9.10

OveReview Final Score

RANK #8

Lance Nekot Peanut Butter Cookies - 40 ct....

$23.8

OveReview Final Score

$23.80

Score By Features

Based on 356 ratings

Flavor
9.58
Value for money
9.28
Freshness
8.98

OveReview Final Score

RANK #9

Nutter Butter Bites Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 12 - 3 o...

$30.29

OveReview Final Score

$30.29

Score By Features

Based on 55 ratings

Satisfaction
9.81
Packaging
9.70
Value for money
9.49
Customer service
9.62

OveReview Final Score

RANK #10

Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 4 Boxes of 12 ...

$17.16

OveReview Final Score

$17.16

Score By Features

Based on 9,201 ratings

Flavor
9.51
Freshness
8.98
Value for money
7.69

OveReview Final Score

RANK #11

Nature Valley Chocolate Biscuits with Peanut Butter, 10 ct, ...

$40.45

OveReview Final Score

$40.45

Score By Features

Based on 325 ratings

Flavor
9.92
Value for money
8.50

OveReview Final Score

RANK #12

Kinder Happy Hippo - Cocoa, CASE, 10x(20.7g x 5)...

$40.99

OveReview Final Score

$40.99

Score By Features

Based on 1,331 ratings

Flavor
9.18
Value for money
8.38

OveReview Final Score

RANK #13

Score By Features

Based on 2,181 ratings

Flavor
9.58
Value for money
9.51
Portion size
8.88

OveReview Final Score

RANK #14

Score By Features

Based on 465 ratings

Flavor
9.68
Value for money
8.58

OveReview Final Score

RANK #15

Nonni’s Limone Biscotti 8 ct (2 Boxes)...

$16.99

OveReview Final Score

$16.99

Score By Features

Based on 36 ratings

Flavor
9.60
Value for money
9.90
Freshness
9.49

OveReview Final Score

RANK #16

Lance Nekot Peanut Butter Cookies, 69.8 Ounce...

$17.99

OveReview Final Score

$17.99

Score By Features

Based on 35 ratings

Flavor
9.90
Value for money
9.60

OveReview Final Score

RANK #17

Celebration Communion Cup 30 Day Devotional Set...

$36.95

OveReview Final Score

$36.95

Score By Features

Based on 367 ratings

Flavor
9.88
Freshness
9.88
Value for money
9.69
Easy to remove
9.48

OveReview Final Score

RANK #18

Score By Features

Based on 1,400 ratings

Flavor
9.08
Value for money
8.10

OveReview Final Score

RANK #19

Genie's Dream Premium Meringue Powder, 16 oz (1 lb) jar...

$22.95

OveReview Final Score

$22.95

Score By Features

Based on 768 ratings

Value for money
8.88
Flavor
8.69
Easy to use
8.48
Easy to spread
8.18

OveReview Final Score

RANK #20

Stauffers Ginger Snaps Bag, 14-Ounce Bags (Pack of 6) Pack o...

$16.01

OveReview Final Score

$16.01

Score By Features

Based on 329 ratings

Giftable
9.90
Satisfaction
9.70
Packaging
9.70
Customer service
9.50

OveReview Final Score

RANK #21

KIT KAT Bar (1.5-OZ Bars, Pack of 36)...

$37.27

OveReview Final Score

$37.27

Score By Features

Based on 366 ratings

Flavor
9.80
Giftable
9.90
Value for money
9.11

OveReview Final Score

RANK #22

Nature Valley™ Almond Butter Biscuits 16ct, 1.35oz...

$20.94

OveReview Final Score

$20.94

Score By Features

Based on 298 ratings

Flavor
8.98
Value for money
6.86

OveReview Final Score

RANK #23

DAELMANS Stroopwafels, Dutch Waffles Soft Toasted, Caramel, ...

$25.51

OveReview Final Score

$25.51

Score By Features

Based on 1,363 ratings

Value for money
9.60
Packaging
9.19
Satisfaction
9.46
Customer service
9.09

OveReview Final Score

RANK #24

Manner Wafers Hazelnut Cream Filled Wafers, 2.54-Ounce (Pack...

$24.35

OveReview Final Score

$24.35

Score By Features

Based on 598 ratings

Flavor
9.08
Value for money
8.92

OveReview Final Score

RANK #25

Keebler Chips Deluxe Rainbow Mini Cookies & Mother's Circus ...

$17.89

OveReview Final Score

$17.89

Score By Features

Based on 351 ratings

Flavor
9.18
Freshness
8.98
Value for money
7.48

OveReview Final Score